Train an apprentice or hire a journeyman? The real math
Train an apprentice or hire a journeyman electrician? Four years of worked math side by side, the risk he leaves, and a plan that does both.
Do both, but hire the journeyman first if you need jobs run inside a year. In our worked example, four years of apprentice costs about $238,000 in wages, school and teaching time, or $47.60 per journeyman-hour of work he turns out. A J-man at $40 costs $40.00 for every hour. The extra buys you a journeyman in year five who learned the work your way.
01Which one to lead with
Lead with whichever hire fixes the hole you have this year. Apprentices fix next year's hole. A journeyman fixes this one.
One commercial contractor told us he'd weighed it out loud: "If you had him, put him through school and pay them, it costs more than just paying someone to get one guy." Then the line that settled it: "We don't have four years. We're looking to run jobs."
| Your situation | Lead with | Why |
|---|---|---|
| You're the only one who can run a job | Journeyman | An apprentice can't run work for years |
| Your J-men run work and spend hours on grunt work | Apprentice | He makes each crew faster |
| Backlog runs 2 or more years out | Both, J-man first | He runs work and has someone to teach |
| No J-man with the time or patience to teach | Journeyman | An apprentice with no teacher is a helper |
| You're at your state's ratio cap | Journeyman | Every new apprentice needs a licensed hand |
If you're still sorting out which seat to fill at all, the bigger picture is in who to hire next as your shop grows. This post is the money behind one choice in it.
02What four years of apprentice costs
A four-year apprentice costs you his wages, his school and the hours your journeyman spends teaching him, and for most of those years he turns out less than a J-man.
Electrician apprenticeships usually run 4 or 5 years, with about 2,000 hours of paid on-the-job training a year plus classroom (BLS Occupational Outlook Handbook). IEC's open-shop program, for one, is about four years with at least 8,000 hours on the job and 576 classroom hours (IEC).
Here's a worked example. Every input is ours, so swap in your own. Say your J-man rate is $40 an hour, your apprentice starts at 50% of it and steps up 10 points a year, and he works 2,000 hours a year. Then say he turns out 40% of what a J-man does in year one, 55% in year two, 70% in year three and 85% in year four.
| Year | Rate | Wages | Output in J-man hours |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | $20 (50%) | $40,000 | 800 |
| 2 | $24 (60%) | $48,000 | 1,100 |
| 3 | $28 (70%) | $56,000 | 1,400 |
| 4 | $32 (80%) | $64,000 | 1,700 |
| Total | $208,000 | 5,000 |
Add two more costs:
- School. Say $2,500 a year for tuition and books. That's $10,000 over four years. Ask your sponsor for the real number.
- Teaching time. Say his journeyman loses 5 hours a week to teaching for 50 weeks a year in years one and two. That's 500 hours at $40, or $20,000.
Total: $208,000 plus $10,000 plus $20,000 is $238,000. Divide by 5,000 J-man hours and he costs $47.60 for each hour of journeyman work. Year one alone runs $50 an hour of output ($40,000 over 800 hours). By year four he's down to about $37.65 ($64,000 over 1,700 hours), cheaper than the J-man.
Are those inputs fair? A $20 first-year sits close to what helpers make: BLS puts the national median for electrician helpers at $20.51 an hour, and $19.91 at electrical contractors (OEWS, May 2025). A $40 J-man sits near the 75th percentile for all electricians, $40.36 (same data). Both are straight time, and the electrician figure includes apprentices, so check live ads in your area. Real wage ladders by year are in what to pay an apprentice electrician.
03What a journeyman costs over the same four years
Same example: a J-man at $40 for 2,000 hours a year is $80,000 a year and $320,000 over four years, for 8,000 hours of journeyman work. That's $40.00 an hour of output from day one.
He costs more in total dollars. He costs less per hour of work. And he can take a set of prints and run a job, which an apprentice won't do for years no matter what you pay him.
What the J-man line leaves out is the cost of finding him. The good ones have jobs, and you're selling a move to a man who doesn't need one. The steps from ad to day one are in how to hire a journeyman electrician who can do the work.
04Side by side
Here is the same example in one table. Both columns are straight time, before burden. Burden runs on top of both wage bills, so it doesn't change which one wins per hour; how to work out labor burden has the line items.
| Over 4 years | Apprentice | Journeyman |
|---|---|---|
| Wages | $208,000 | $320,000 |
| School and teaching | $30,000 | $0 |
| Total | $238,000 | $320,000 |
| J-man hours of output | 5,000 | 8,000 |
| Cost per J-man hour | $47.60 | $40.00 |
| Can run a job | Not for years | Day one |
| In year five | A J-man who learned your way | The same J-man |
So the owner who said training "costs more" was right per hour of work. The apprentice wins on total payroll and on what you have at the end, if he's still with you.
05The risk he leaves after you train him
The worst case is an apprentice who leaves in year two or three, right when he's starting to pay you back.
Same example: say he leaves at the end of year two. You paid $88,000 in wages, $5,000 in school and all $20,000 of teaching time, $113,000 in total, for 1,900 J-man hours of work. That's about $59.47 an hour, and nobody's left to show for it.
Two things cut that risk:
- Register him. Apprenticeship.gov says 90% of apprentices continue employment after they finish a registered apprenticeship. That's employment in general, not with the shop that trained them, but a registered program ties raises and school to you. Federal standards require "a progressively increasing schedule of wages" (29 CFR 29.5), so he can see every step coming. How to start a registered electrical apprenticeship program covers the setup and one shop's tuition deposit.
- Pay the steps on time and show him the next card. A raise due at 1,000 hours paid at 1,000 hours. Real numbers for what a journeyman and a foreman make with you.
What a trained hand costs you when he walks is worked out in what it costs when a journeyman quits.
06Why shops with their own apprenticeship still hire off the street
Even a shop that grows its own still has to buy experience, because a fourth-year can't run the job a 10-year hand can.
One contractor that runs its own apprenticeship told us its program turns out fourth-years, and it still wants hands with 3 to 5 years off the street. The apprentices fill the crews. The experienced hires run them and teach the next class.
That's the pattern to copy. Your apprentice program is only as good as the journeymen it trains under. Short on J-men means short on teachers.
07The ratio decides how many apprentices one J-man buys you
Every licensed hand you add raises how many apprentices you can legally carry, so a journeyman hire can be the thing that makes training possible.
As of 2026, state ratios we checked run from 1 to 3 apprentices per licensed electrician. In a 3 to 1 state, one more J-man opens up to three apprentice seats. In a 1 to 1 state, one. Confirm with your state board, and see apprentice to journeyman ratio rules by state for the statutes.
08A plan that does both
Hire the journeyman first, then put apprentices under him once he's settled. Here's the order, with the same example numbers.
- Hire one J-man to run work. He takes a job off your plate in month one.
- Give him 60 to 90 days to learn your jobs before you hand him anyone to teach.
- Add two apprentices under him, if your state ratio allows two.
- Raise them on schedule and move the crew to bigger work as they climb.
The crew math, ignoring school and teaching time: one J-man and two apprentices cost $80 an hour in year one, the same as two J-men. Using the output shares above, that crew turns out 1.8 J-man hours an hour, or about $44.44 per J-man hour. By year three it's $96 for 2.4, or $40.00, even with two J-men. By year four it's $104 for 2.7, about $38.52, and you have two hands close to their cards.
A helper is a third option when the work is material and grunt work, not wiring. Hiring an electrical helper covers what he can legally do.
If you need journeymen now to run jobs and teach the apprentices you're bringing on, see the electricians we already have near you. No money up front. If you don't hire, you don't pay.
Got more work than guys?
We already found them: 238 qualified electricians, 5+ years each. See who we have near you. No money up front. If you don't hire, you don't pay.
See who we haveFAQFAQs
Is it cheaper to train an apprentice than hire a journeyman?
In total dollars, usually yes. Per hour of finished work, usually no, until his last year or so. In our example the apprentice costs $238,000 over four years against $320,000 for a J-man, but $47.60 per hour of journeyman work against $40.00.
How long until an apprentice can run work on his own?
Not until he's close to his card, and often later. Apprenticeships run 4 or 5 years at about 2,000 paid hours a year, per BLS, and running a job takes more than hours. Most shops put a new journeyman under a foreman for a while before giving him his own crew.
What does an apprentice electrician cost a contractor per year?
His wages, his school and the teaching time, plus burden. In our example a first-year at $20 an hour for 2,000 hours is $40,000 in wages, and school at an example $2,500 brings it to $42,500 before burden and teaching time. Your sponsor sets the real tuition.
Can I make an apprentice pay back his training if he leaves?
Some shops use a deposit or a repayment agreement, like one IEC contractor that asks apprentices to put up $1,000 to start school and gives it back if they're still there at graduation (IEC). Rules on wage deductions and repayment vary by state, so put it in writing and run it past an employment lawyer first.
Sources
- Bureau of Labor Statistics, Occupational Outlook Handbook, Electricians
- Bureau of Labor Statistics, OEWS May 2025, Electricians (47-2111)
- Bureau of Labor Statistics, OEWS May 2025, Helpers, Electricians (47-3013)
- Bureau of Labor Statistics, OEWS data tables (industry estimates for electrical contractors)
- U.S. Department of Labor, Apprenticeship.gov, Registered Apprenticeship Program
- eCFR via Cornell LII, 29 CFR 29.5, Standards of apprenticeship
- Independent Electrical Contractors, Apprenticeship
- IEC, Workforce development spotlight: recruitment and retention
