How to hire an electrical estimator who stays
How to hire an electrical estimator: grow one from the field or hire one, what a real one shows you, a paid test bid, BLS pay data and how to keep him.
To hire an electrical estimator who stays, test him on a set of drawings you already bid, pay him for that test, and pick someone who lives close and wants a path to PM. Pay is the floor: estimators at electrical contractors had a median of $92,900 a year, $44.67 an hour (BLS OEWS, May 2025).
01Why estimators don't last at a growing shop
Most estimator hires fail for one of three reasons: he can't really estimate electrical, the drive wears him out, or he has nowhere to go after a few years.
One contractor told us he hired five estimators in ten years through recruiters and paid each recruiter 18 to 25% of the estimator's salary. None of the five stayed. Say you hire at the electrical contractor median of $92,900. That's $16,722 to $23,225 a fee. Five of them is $83,610 to $116,125 spent on estimators who are gone.
His three stories cover most of what goes wrong:
- The fake. A recruiting service sent him one "estimator" who had never done electrical work.
- The drive. A good one lived an hour and a half away. He said the drive was fine. A month in, it wasn't.
- The good one who left. His best estimator came up from his own field crew, knew the work cold, and later went out on his own.
The first one is a screening problem. The second is a commute problem. The third is a career problem. Each has a fix below.
Another contractor told us he's "probably fired seven" estimators. His lesson was field time: "Anybody can count dots." He'd also tried an out-of-state estimating service. He told us it priced a job he had at about $250,000 at close to $600,000, because "their codes are just different and their pricing is different." Your estimator has to know your codes, your supply house and your crews.
If you're still deciding whether an estimator is the right next hire at all, who to hire as your shop grows covers the order most shops add people in.
02Grow one from the field or hire one?
Grow one from the field if you have a J-man or foreman who reads prints fast and wants off the tools. Hire one if you need bids out next month and nobody on your crew can do a takeoff.
| Grow from the field | Hire an estimator | |
|---|---|---|
| Knows electrical | Yes, he's installed it | Check it. Some never have |
| Knows your costs and crews | Yes | No, takes months |
| Software and bid day | Has to learn | Should already know |
| Time to bids on his own | Often 6 to 12 months (example) | Weeks, if he's real |
| Risk | He leaves the field short a hand | You pay a fee for a fake |
| Why he leaves | Goes out on his own | Better offer or a shorter drive |
The field hand's big edge is that he knows how long things take on your jobs, with your foremen. An outside estimator can price a takeoff, but his labor units come from somewhere else until he learns your numbers. One estimator candidate with decades in the field told us you need field experience "because you can see it from start to finish."
BLS backs the field route. Its Occupational Outlook Handbook says "some construction cost estimators become qualified solely through extensive work experience," and that workers with several years in construction sometimes qualify without a degree (BLS, Cost Estimators).
The same habits that make a good foreman often make a good estimator: reading prints, thinking a job through before it starts, knowing what a crew can put in a day. When a journeyman is ready to run work covers how to spot that hand. Some shops do both: hire one experienced estimator now and train a field hand under him.
03What a real electrical estimator should show you
A real one can sit down with a set of drawings and walk you through his takeoff out loud. Ask for these five things before you make an offer.
- A takeoff from a real set. Hand him a set you already bid. Watch how he counts devices, measures runs and builds the gear schedule. A fake stalls on the first panel schedule.
- The software he's used. Electrical estimating runs on its own programs, like Accubid, McCormick or ConEst, plus a takeoff tool. Ask which one, for how long, and have him show you a bid he built in it.
- His bid-day story. Ask about the last bid he turned in at the deadline. Who sent late addenda, which quotes came in last, what he cut or added. Someone who's done it tells it in detail.
- His hit rate and job size. Ask what share of his bids he won and what size jobs they were. Then ask why the ones he lost were lost. The number matters less than whether he knows it.
- Where his labor units came from. Ask how he adjusts the program's labor units for a crew. If he says he never does, he's typing, not estimating.
Listen to what he asks you, too. The good ones ask whether they'd be bidding against other shops or pricing work you've already won, and who handles change orders. "If you don't get those change orders in, you're gonna lose money for your company," that candidate told us. Someone who never asks hasn't carried a job past the bid.
Then call the people he worked for. Ask whether jobs he priced made money in the field. That's the one question that tells you if his numbers hold up.
04Run a paid test bid
The best test is a paid one: give him a job you already bid and built, pay him for the day, and compare his number to yours and to what the job really cost.
Here's how to set it up:
- Pick a finished job of a size he'd bid for you, with a clean set of drawings and your final job cost.
- Strip your numbers out. Give him the drawings, the specs and the scope letter.
- Give him a day, at your office or his.
- Pay him for it. Say you pay $45 an hour for 8 hours: that's $360.
- Go through his number line by line with him. Where he's off from your bid and your final cost tells you more than the total.
He doesn't have to hit your number. What you're looking for is a takeoff that's complete, a labor number he can defend, and the stuff he flagged that you missed.
A paid test also tells the good ones you take the job seriously. Someone who won't spend a paid day on a test isn't someone you want pricing your work.
05What to pay an electrical estimator
Pay at or above the electrical contractor numbers, not the all-industry ones. Estimators at electrical contractors earn more than estimators overall.
| Cost estimators, May 2025 | Median | Mean | Employment |
|---|---|---|---|
| All industries | $78,740 ($37.86 an hour) | $85,390 ($41.06 an hour) | 224,220 |
| Electrical contractors | $92,900 ($44.67 an hour) | $94,950 ($45.65 an hour) | 14,730 |
Source: BLS Occupational Employment and Wage Statistics, May 2025, cost estimators (13-1051). "Electrical contractors" is NAICS 238210, electrical contractors and other wiring installation contractors. These are base wages only, no bonus or benefits.
The spread is wide. At electrical contractors, the bottom 10% earned under $58,970 a year and the top 10% over $134,110 (BLS OEWS, May 2025). A field hand you're training sits near the bottom of that range at first. An estimator who prices big commercial work on his own sits near the top.
Base is only half the offer. How to build the bonus side, on margin and not just volume, is in estimator pay and bonus plans that work.
Hold the number up against what your top journeymen make. A field hand won't come in off the tools to take less than he made running work.
06Don't hire a long drive
Hire someone who lives within about an hour of the office, and test the drive before the offer. An estimator is in the office most days, out walking jobs on others, and stays late on bid days, so a long drive hits him harder than a field hand.
The estimator who lived an hour and a half out said the drive was fine. He meant it. He just hadn't done it for a month of bid deadlines yet. Ask him to drive it once at the hour he'd really leave home, before you make the offer. Then ask him again how it went. How far electricians will drive every day covers the commute question in full.
If the best person lives far out, talk about a hybrid week up front. Takeoffs can be done from home. Bid day, site walks and meetings with your PMs can't. The contractor who fired seven wants his estimator walking jobs and selling: hybrid, not remote, and not 9 to 5. Put that in the ad so nobody finds out a month in.
07How to keep him
Keep him by showing him where the job goes in three to five years. Estimators leave for one of two places: a bigger shop that pays more, or their own shop.
- A path to PM. Let him run a job he bid. An estimator who sees his own numbers built learns faster and has a reason to stay.
- A piece of what he wins. A bonus tied to jobs that made money, not jobs that were won. Winning at a loss is easy.
- A seat at the table. Put him in the room for go or no-go calls on bids. He'll feel like part of the company, not a calculator.
- Talk about ownership early. The best ones want to own something. If there's a path to buy in, say so. If there isn't, know that the good one may leave to start his own shop, like the one we heard about did.
Expect a counteroffer when you hire a good one away. The contractor who fired seven told us his last good finalist took a $5,000 raise from his own boss and stayed. Ask every finalist what he'll do if his boss counters, before you send the offer. How a shop decides whether to match an offer shows the math his boss is running.
The broader moves that keep people, like stay interviews and raise schedules, are in how to keep good electricians.
08If you use a recruiter
Use one only if he'll put a test bid in front of every person he sends, you pay nothing until the hire starts, and you've read what happens if he leaves in the first 90 days.
Ask how he checks that someone has done electrical takeoffs, not general construction or a different trade. What separates a staffing agency from a recruiter lays out how each one gets paid, and questions to ask a recruiting company before you sign has the list for that first call.
If you need the estimator or the hands in the field, see who we already have near you. No money up front. If you don't hire, you don't pay.
Got more work than guys?
We already found them: 238 qualified electricians, 5+ years each. See who we have near you. No money up front. If you don't hire, you don't pay.
See who we haveFAQFAQs
How much does an electrical estimator make?
Cost estimators at electrical contractors had a median wage of $92,900 a year, or $44.67 an hour, in May 2025, per BLS. Across all industries the median was $78,740. The bottom 10% at electrical contractors earned under $58,970 and the top 10% over $134,110.
Can an electrician become an estimator without a degree?
Yes. BLS says some construction cost estimators qualify solely through work experience. A J-man or foreman who reads prints fast and knows how long work takes on your jobs is often the best starting point. He'll need to learn the software and bid day.
How long does it take to train an estimator from the field?
It depends on the hand and the work you bid. As a rough example, many shops have a field hand pricing small jobs on his own within months and bigger bids within a year, with a senior estimator or the owner checking his numbers the whole time.
What should I ask an electrical estimator in an interview?
Ask which estimating software he's used and for how long, to walk you through his last bid day, what share of his bids he won, and how he adjusts labor units for a crew. Then give him a paid test bid on drawings you've already priced.
Should I pay a recruiter to find an estimator?
Only with a test bid built into the process and refund terms you've read. One contractor told us he paid recruiters 18 to 25% of salary for five estimators over ten years and none of them stayed.
