The job site walk: an interview a fake journeyman can't pass
An electrician job site interview in 30 to 45 minutes: who walks him, six stops, what to point at and ask, green and red flags, scoring and site safety.
An electrician job site interview is a 30 to 45 minute walk through a live job with the foreman or field engineer he'd work under. Stop at the gear, a pull, rough-in, the drawings and the other trades' equipment, point at things and ask what he'd do. A real journeyman asks good questions. A fake one asks what things are.
One commercial contractor told us he dropped the office interview for this reason: "A guy comes in the office and tells you everything he thinks you want to hear." Now it's one phone call, then a field engineer meets the man on a job and walks him around. On one of those walks, the applicant looked at an elevator controller and asked, "What's that?" The walk was over.
The walk is one step in hiring a journeyman electrician who can do the work. It comes after the phone screen and sits next to, or in place of, a bench test.
01Why a walk beats an office interview
A walk tests what he knows in the place he'll use it, so rehearsed answers don't help him.
In an office, a man can describe a job he watched someone else run. On a floor, you point at a 400 amp panel with the feeders landed and ask what he'd check before it gets energized. He either knows or he doesn't, and he can't steer the talk back to what he's good at.
It also shows habits no question gets at: does he look up at the tray, notice a missing strap, ask what phase the job is in?
The federal Office of Personnel Management defines a structured interview as one where "all candidates are asked the same predetermined questions in the same order" and every answer is rated on the same scale (OPM). A walk can be structured too: same stops, same questions, same score sheet, every applicant.
02Who walks him
The person who walks him should be the one who'd catch a wrong answer, which means a field engineer, superintendent or the foreman he'd work under.
Not the office manager, and usually not an owner who's been off the tools for ten years. If the foreman is the one who'll be stuck with him, let the foreman walk him. A foreman's no should end it.
03Where it fits in your hiring
The walk goes after the phone screen and before the offer. Here's one way to lay it out:
| Step | Time | What it settles |
|---|---|---|
| Phone screen | 15 min | Card, rank, the trade basics, leave risk |
| Job site walk | 30 to 45 min | How he thinks on a real job |
| Bench test (optional) | 30 min | Whether his hands match his talk |
| Offer | Same day or next | Rate, hours, start date |
Run the phone screen questions that catch a laborer first so you're not walking helpers around a site. Look up his card before he drives out.
Some shops use the walk instead of a bench test. That works if your walker is sharp, but the walk tests his head, and the 30-minute bench test tests his hands. If his answers on the walk are good and you still aren't sure he can bend, hand him a stick of EMT at the gang box before he leaves.
04The six stops
Pick a job in the middle of rough-in or early trim, when the most work is visible. Plan the route before he shows up and use it for every applicant on that job.
1. The electrical room
Start where the gear is, because a journeyman should be comfortable there and a laborer won't be.
Stand outside the door if anything inside is energized. Ask:
- "Walk me through what's in here and how it's fed."
- "This switchboard gets energized next week. What do you want checked before then?"
- "Which of these would you want a second set of eyes on, and why?"
A real hand traces the feed and talks about torque marks, phasing, covers and who's clear. A fake one names a couple of parts and stops.
2. A pull, in progress or coming up
Ask him how he'd set up the next big wire pull, because pulls show planning, crew and safety in one answer.
- "This feeder goes from here to the third floor panel. How do you set it up?"
- "How many men, and where do you put them?"
Listen for the reels and where they sit, the rope or tugger, lube, the sock or basket, who's feeding, how they talk to each other, and where it could hang up. A hand who has run big pulls will ask how many bends are in the run before he answers.
3. Rough-in waiting on inspection
Walk a stretch of rough-in and ask what an inspector would write up, because finding mistakes is half of running work.
Before he gets there, have your foreman plant or leave one or two things: a missing strap, an overfilled box, a missing nail plate, a bonding jumper left off. Use the same ones for every applicant on that job.
A real journeyman finds at least one without being pointed at it. A good one also says what he'd do about it and who he'd tell.
4. The drawings and the panel schedule
Hand him the plan set or the tablet and ask him to find something, because reading prints is the job now, not a bonus. "Read blueprints or technical diagrams" is the first duty the BLS lists for electricians.
- "Find the homerun for this circuit and show me where it lands."
- "What feeds this panel?"
- "This mechanical unit moved two feet. Where would you look to see if it changes your work?"
The last question matters more every year. A foreman today keeps track of electrical, architectural, mechanical and shop drawings plus submittals. A journeyman who has never looked past the E sheets will struggle. If you're hiring a lead, go deeper with the electrical foreman interview questions.
5. Other trades' equipment
Point at something that isn't yours and ask what it is and what it needs from you, because this is where the fakes show.
An elevator controller, a fire alarm panel, a rooftop unit's disconnect, a fire pump controller. He doesn't have to have wired one. He should know what it is, that it needs power and a disconnect, and who he'd coordinate with. "What's that?" about an elevator controller on a commercial job is a red flag on its own.
6. The gang box
End at the gang box or the container, because how a man talks about tools and material tells you how he'll run a day.
- "You're short on 3/4 connectors and it's 10 a.m. What do you do?"
- "What do you bring yourself, and what do you expect us to have?"
A hand who keeps material ahead of the crew counts it before it runs out.
05What to listen for
His questions matter as much as his answers, because a real journeyman is sizing up your job while you size him up.
| Green flag | Red flag |
|---|---|
| Asks what phase the job is in and how long it runs | Agrees with everything you say |
| Asks who the GC is and how the super is to work with | Asks what a common piece of gear is |
| Spots a problem in the rough-in on his own | Walks past a missing strap or overfilled box |
| Talks about a pull in steps, with men placed | "We just pull it" |
| Opens the drawings to the right sheet without help | Can't find a circuit on the panel schedule |
| Says "I" and names sizes, amps and brands | Says "we" and "whatever they needed" |
| Asks about material on site and how it's ordered | Talks about himself the whole walk |
One owner put the whole point of the walk in one line: "I need electricians. I don't need guys that say they're electricians."
06How to score it
Score each stop 1, 3 or 5 right after the walk, on one sheet, before you talk to anyone else about him.
| Stop | 1 | 3 | 5 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Electrical room | Couldn't say how it's fed | Got the feed, thin on checks | Traced it and listed real pre-energize checks |
| The pull | No plan | A plan, missed the hang-ups | Set it up step by step, asked about the bends |
| Rough-in | Found nothing | Found one with a hint | Found the plants on his own and said who he'd tell |
| Drawings | Couldn't find the circuit | Found it slowly | Found it and checked the other trades' sheets |
| Other trades | Didn't know what it was | Knew it, not what it needs | Knew it, the power it needs and who to call |
| Gang box | No answer | A fair answer | Keeps material ahead without being told |
Here's an example pass mark, not a standard: 20 out of 30, with no 1 on the electrical room or the rough-in. Write down what a 1, 3 and 5 look like for your work before the first walk, so two walkers land in the same place.
Then weigh his questions. A man who scored 18 but asked sharp ones may be worth a bench test.
07Safety and site rules for the walk
He isn't your employee yet, so treat him like any visitor: signed in, in PPE, escorted, and hands off.
- Clear it with the GC. Most sites need visitors signed in and walked by someone on the job. Ask the super the day before.
- PPE before he steps on site. Hard hat, glasses, vest and boots, or whatever the site requires. OSHA's construction rule says protective equipment "shall be provided, used, and maintained" wherever the hazards call for it (29 CFR 1926.95). Keep a spare hard hat and glasses in the truck.
- Nobody touches energized gear. Not him, not the walker. OSHA's construction rule for electrical work says employers must find out where energized circuits are and tell employees "the location of such lines, the hazards involved, and the protective measures to be taken" (29 CFR 1926.416). A visitor gets less access than that, not more. Talk from the doorway.
- No tools, no work. The walk is talk. If he starts helping a crew pull, he's working, and the Department of Labor says work "suffered or permitted to be performed is work time that must be paid for" (DOL Fact Sheet #22). If you want to see his hands on a real task, make it a paid trial on the payroll.
- Same walk for everyone on that job, so the score means something.
08When the walk isn't possible
No live job nearby, or a GC that won't allow visitors? Do the walk on the drawings and photos instead.
Sit at a plan table with one sheet from each stop and photos from a current job, and ask the same questions. It's weaker than standing in the room, but still harder to fake than "tell me about yourself."
Agency hands are a special case. If an agency is sending a man straight to your site, run the first hour like a walk; why agencies send journeymen who can't bend pipe covers what to check before he travels.
If you'd rather spend your time walking good applicants than sorting bad ones, see the electricians we already have near you. No money up front. If you don't hire, you don't pay.
Got more work than guys?
We already found them: 238 qualified electricians, 5+ years each. See who we have near you. No money up front. If you don't hire, you don't pay.
See who we haveFAQFAQs
How long should a job site interview take?
Thirty to 45 minutes. That's enough for six stops and his questions, and short enough that a working journeyman can do it before or after his shift. If it runs past an hour, you're probably teaching instead of asking.
Do I have to pay an applicant for a job site walk?
A walk where he only looks and answers questions is an interview, not work. If he picks up tools or helps a crew, federal law treats that as hours worked, and state rules on tryouts vary. When in doubt, put him on the payroll for that time and check with your employment lawyer.
Can I do a job site interview on a GC's site?
Usually, if you ask the super first and follow the site's visitor rules: sign-in, orientation if required, PPE and an escort the whole time. Some sites, like hospitals and data centers, won't allow it. Use the drawings and photos version there.
What should a journeyman ask on a job site interview?
A real hand usually asks what phase the job is in, how long it runs, who the GC is, whether material is on site, and who he'd work under. If he asks nothing about the job, he's either not interested or doesn't know what matters.
Sources
- U.S. Office of Personnel Management, Structured Interviews
- OSHA, 29 CFR 1926.95, Criteria for personal protective equipment
- OSHA, 29 CFR 1926.416, General requirements (electrical, construction)
- U.S. Department of Labor, Fact Sheet #22: Hours Worked Under the FLSA
- Bureau of Labor Statistics, Electricians, Occupational Outlook Handbook
