Commission pay for service electricians: is it a good deal?
Service electrician commission pay, checked: what the law still owes you on a slow week, unpaid wait at home, and slow vs busy week math against hourly.
Commission-only pay is a good deal for a fast service electrician who likes selling, in a shop where the phone never stops. Anywhere else it puts every slow week on you. The law still sets a floor: each week's pay divided by hours worked has to reach minimum wage, and hours over 40 get overtime (U.S. Department of Labor).
01What "strictly commission" means on a service van
Strictly commission means you only get paid when a job is sold, and there's no hourly rate under it.
That's the one plan where the shop carries none of the slow-week risk. Here's how it stacks up against the other plans service shops use:
| Plan | What you get | Who eats a slow week |
|---|---|---|
| Strictly commission | A percent of what you sell or collect | You |
| Draw against commission | A set advance each week, paid back out of commission | Mostly you |
| Hourly plus commission | Your rate, plus a percent on top | Mostly the shop |
| Flat rate per task | A set amount per task from the price book | You, if calls are thin |
| Straight hourly | Rate times hours | The shop |
The headline percent tells you almost nothing by itself. 20% of a busy shop's calls can beat a good hourly rate. 30% of a dead shop's calls won't. For a benchmark, the median electrician made $30.38 an hour in May 2025, straight time, apprentices included (BLS, Electricians). Where journeyman pay sits in 2026 breaks that number down by state and metro.
If you're still deciding whether service work suits you at all, start with whether service electrician work is worth it. This post is about one question: the commission offer in front of you.
02What the law still owes you on commission
On commission you're still owed at least minimum wage for every hour worked each week, plus overtime over 40.
Four rules matter:
- Minimum wage, week by week. For non-hourly pay, the week's earnings divided by the week's hours is your regular rate, and "in no case may the regular rate be less than the minimum wage" (DOL, Handy Reference Guide to the FLSA). Federal minimum is $7.25 an hour (DOL, Minimum wage). Many states set it higher, and the DOL says employers "must comply with both" (DOL, State minimum wage laws).
- Each week stands alone. "Averaging of hours over two or more weeks is not permitted" (DOL Fact Sheet 23). A big week doesn't cover a bad one.
- Overtime on commission. Commissions "are payments for hours worked and must be included in the regular rate," even when commission is all you get (29 CFR 778.117). Add up the week, divide by hours, and every hour over 40 gets an extra half of that rate (29 CFR 778.118).
- Spiffs count too. A bonus you know about ahead of time, like a set amount per panel sold, is nondiscretionary and goes into the regular rate (DOL Fact Sheet 56C).
There's one exception a shop might point to. Section 7(i) lets a "retail or service establishment" skip overtime on commission pay, but only if your regular rate is more than one and a half times minimum wage for every hour in that week and more than half your pay over a representative period is commission. The establishment also has to have 75% of its sales not for resale and recognized as retail in its industry (DOL Fact Sheet 20). Whether an electrical service shop qualifies is a legal call. If a shop says it does, ask the Department of Labor, not the shop.
None of this is legal advice. It's what to know before you sign. More on what you're owed is in your rights on the job.
03Sitting at home waiting for the call
Time at home waiting for dispatch is usually unpaid, and on strictly commission that wait is where the money leaks out.
One shop owner told us about a competitor down the road that pays its service techs "strictly commission, there is no hourly guarantee." A tech there can sit at home for eight hours before dispatch calls and sends him somewhere. Then he has to quote the job and talk the customer into buying it to make anything. The owner's verdict: "I don't like paying people like that."
The law splits waiting into two kinds:
- Engaged to wait. You're on the clock. A repair man who waits while the customer gets the place ready "is working," even if he can leave the site (29 CFR 785.15).
- Waiting to be engaged. You're off the clock if you're told you're free until a set time and it's long enough to use for yourself (29 CFR 785.16).
On-call at home works the same way. If you only have to leave word where you can be reached, you're "not working while on call" (29 CFR 785.17). More limits on your freedom can change that (DOL Fact Sheet 22). Driving from one call to the next during the day is work time and has to be counted.
Here's why it matters on commission. The minimum wage floor is figured on hours worked. If the eight hours at home don't count, a thin week can clear the floor on paper while you were tied to your phone all week.
04A slow week and a busy week, side by side
On commission, a busy week can look close to hourly pay, but one slow week can wipe out the gap.
Worked example (our numbers, for illustration only). A tech gets 20% of the work he sells. His other offer is $30 an hour, close to the BLS median.
Busy week: 50 hours, $7,000 sold.
| Commission | Hourly at $30 | |
|---|---|---|
| Straight pay | $1,400 (20% of $7,000) | $1,200 (40 x $30) |
| Regular rate | $28 ($1,400 / 50) | $30 |
| Overtime | $140 (10 x $14 half-time) | $450 (10 x $45) |
| Week's pay | $1,540 | $1,650 |
Slow week: 40 hours worked, $1,000 sold.
| Commission | Hourly at $30 | |
|---|---|---|
| Commission or wages | $200 (20% of $1,000) | $1,200 |
| Regular rate | $5 ($200 / 40) | $30 |
| Federal floor | $290 (40 x $7.25) | n/a |
| Week's pay | $290, shop tops up $90 | $1,200 |
Over the two weeks, commission pays $1,830 ($1,540 + $290) and hourly pays $2,850 ($1,650 + $1,200). That's $1,020 apart, and the busy week wasn't enough to close it. In a state with a higher minimum wage, the slow-week floor is higher, but nowhere near $1,200.
Now say only 15 of those slow-week hours get counted, because the rest was waiting at home. $200 / 15 is $13.33 an hour. That clears the federal floor, so the shop owes no top-up. Same week for you, less money.
Last, the break-even. To match $30 an hour on a 40-hour week at 20%, you'd have to sell $6,000 every week ($1,200 / 0.20). Ask the shop what its average tech actually sells in a week. If they can't or won't say, that's your answer.
05Questions to ask before you take a commission offer
Ask these out loud and get the answers in the offer letter, because commission plans live in the details.
- Is there any hourly floor or draw, and do I pay a draw back if I come up short?
- Percent of what: sold, collected, or after materials? Materials off before or after the percent?
- When do I get paid: when the job's sold, or when the customer pays?
- What happens on a callback? Does commission come back out?
- How many calls does an average tech run a week, and what does he sell?
- Which hours get counted: drive time between calls, waiting at a customer's, shop time, meetings?
- How do you figure overtime on commission weeks?
- Is the van, fuel and tools on you or on me?
On a draw, the rule says advances are normally smaller than expected commission, and whether a shortfall gets deducted later "may or may not be customary" (29 CFR 779.416). So ask. When you've got two offers in hand, compare the whole check side by side before you sign.
06When commission beats hourly, and when it doesn't
Commission beats hourly when the calls are steady and you can close, and it loses when either one is missing.
Commission tends to work for you when:
- The shop runs enough calls to keep you busy 40 hours, every week.
- You like talking to customers and can price a fix in front of them without feeling like a car salesman.
- The plan has a floor or a draw you don't owe back.
- Hours get counted honestly, including drive time between calls.
Hourly tends to work better when:
- Calls are seasonal or the shop is new.
- You hate selling, even honest selling.
- You've got a family budget that can't take a $290 week.
- The shop dodges the questions above.
If you're on strictly commission now and your slow weeks keep landing near the floor, you're probably not the problem. Check the signs you're underpaid, then see how commercial and residential pay compare before you decide whether to ask for a floor or move.
Get your local pay report to see what electricians with your license make near you. Takes about a minute and your boss never hears about it.
See what your license pays near you.
Tap a few answers and see what electricians with your license make in your area. Free, about a minute, and your boss never hears about it.
Get my local pay reportFAQFAQs
Is commission-only pay legal for electricians?
Yes, under federal law a shop can pay a non-exempt electrician by commission alone. But every week, total pay divided by hours worked has to hit at least minimum wage, and hours over 40 still get overtime unless a narrow exception applies. Your state may set a higher minimum.
What is a draw against commission?
A draw is a set amount paid each week or pay period, usually less than the commission you're expected to earn. Commission is then set against it. Some plans take back any shortfall from later weeks and some don't, so ask which one you're signing.
Do I get overtime if I'm paid commission?
Usually, yes. Your week's commission divided by your hours is your regular rate, and every hour over 40 gets an extra half of that rate. A shop can skip it only if it qualifies as a retail or service establishment and your pay meets the 7(i) conditions.
Should I take a commission service job over an hourly one?
Only if you know how many calls the shop runs and what an average tech sells a week. Run your own slow week through the plan. If you can't live on that week, take the hourly offer or ask for a floor.
Sources
- U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Occupational Outlook Handbook, Electricians (May 2025 pay)
- U.S. Department of Labor, Handy Reference Guide to the Fair Labor Standards Act
- U.S. Department of Labor, Minimum wage
- U.S. Department of Labor, State minimum wage laws
- U.S. Department of Labor, Fact Sheet 23, Overtime pay requirements of the FLSA
- U.S. Department of Labor, Fact Sheet 20, Employees paid commissions by retail establishments under Section 7(i)
- U.S. Department of Labor, Fact Sheet 22, Hours worked under the FLSA
- U.S. Department of Labor, Fact Sheet 56C, Bonuses under the FLSA
- 29 CFR 778.117, Commission payments, general
- 29 CFR 778.118, Commission paid on a workweek basis
- 29 CFR 779.416, What compensation "represents commissions"
- 29 CFR 785.15, On duty
- 29 CFR 785.16, Off duty
- 29 CFR 785.17, On-call time
