Replace temp electricians with permanent employees: a plan
How to replace temp electricians with permanent employees on a long job: the math on a 1.16 to 1.2 markup, who to convert first, and clauses to read.
To replace temp electricians with permanent employees, convert the temps you'd hire anyway once their conversion fee is low, hire direct for the rest, and keep a few temps for peaks. At a 1.16 to 1.2 multiplier, more than half the agency's spread is payroll tax you'd pay anyway (BLS, June 2026), so the reason to switch is keeping the crew, not the rate.
01What a 1.16 to 1.2 multiplier really costs
At a low multiplier the agency's spread is thinner than most owners think, because payroll taxes and comp come out of it first.
One data center contractor told us he's running close to 100 temps on his campuses and wants to replace "as many as we can get" with his own hires. His agency multiplier runs "1.2 max, 1.16 is low," billed weekly. That's well under the 30 to 40% markups other contractors report, covered in what agencies mark up an electrician.
Example only: a journeyman paid $40 an hour, straight time, 2,080 hours a year. For private construction in June 2026, BLS puts legally required costs (Social Security, Medicare, unemployment and workers' comp) at $4.42 an hour on $36.13 in wages, or 12.23% on top (our math). On $40, that's $4.89.
| Multiplier | Bill rate | Spread per hour | Payroll tax and comp | Left for the agency |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1.16 | $46.40 | $6.40 | $4.89 | $1.51 |
| 1.20 | $48.00 | $8.00 | $4.89 | $3.11 |
Per hand over a year, what's left for the agency is $3,141 at 1.16 and $6,469 at 1.2 (our math, $1.51 and $3.11 x 2,080). Across 100 hands that's $314,080 to $646,880 a year. Real money, but it's not the whole $6.40 to $8.00 you see on the invoice.
Before you trust the multiplier, ask what it's multiplied against. Is the pay rate what the hand actually makes? Is overtime billed at the same multiplier? Is per diem passed through at cost or marked up? Backing the hand's wage out of a bill rate shows how to get those answers in writing.
02When your own hand costs more per hour
Once you add benefits, your own hand can cost more per hour than a temp at 1.2. That's normal, and it isn't the reason to stay on temps.
BLS shows private construction employers paying $3.90 an hour for insurance and $2.39 for retirement (June 2026), $6.29 together. Add that to the same $40 hand:
| Your own hand | Per hour | vs 1.16 ($46.40) | vs 1.20 ($48.00) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Wage plus payroll tax and comp | $44.89 | $1.51 less | $3.11 less |
| Plus construction-average insurance and retirement | $51.18 | $4.78 more | $3.18 more |
So at a 1.16 to 1.2 multiplier, you're not converting to save on the hourly rate. You're converting for what the agency can't sell you:
- The crew stays yours. An agency hand is the agency's employee. It can move him to a job paying a bigger markup, and you start over.
- You pick the hands. The same contractor wants 3 to 5 years' experience off the street, because his own apprenticeship already turns out 4th-years.
- The next job. A hand on your payroll can follow you to the next campus. A temp follows the agency.
- Benefits that keep people. The insurance and retirement in that second row are part of why a hand stays three years instead of three months.
Your own burden will differ by state, comp rate and plan. Build it line by line with the electrician labor burden guide before you set offers. For the full side-by-side at higher markups, start with staffing agency vs direct hire for electricians.
03Cash flow: a cost that lands once vs a bill every week
The markup lands every week the hand is there. A direct hire's finding cost lands once.
That same contractor said the weekly bill feels easier on cash than paying to hire up front. Per hand, the weekly spread at 1.2 on the $40 example is $320 at 40 hours ($8 x 40). On 100 hands that's $32,000 a week, and about $19,560 of it is payroll tax and comp you'd owe anyway ($4.89 x 40 x 100).
Here's how a one-time hiring cost pays back against the part the agency keeps, before benefits. Example costs only:
| One-time cost to hire one hand | At 1.2 ($3.11 an hour) | At 1.16 ($1.51 an hour) |
|---|---|---|
| $1,500 | 482 hrs, about 12 weeks at 40 | 993 hrs, about 25 weeks at 40 |
| $3,000 | 965 hrs, about 24 weeks at 40 | 1,987 hrs, about 50 weeks at 40 |
On a campus job that runs years, either one pays back inside the job. On a four-month job, a temp at 1.16 may be the cheaper call. Weekly billing is easier on this month's cash, but over a long job it costs more in total.
04Which temps to convert first
Convert the ones you'd hire off the street tomorrow. Everyone else gets replaced, not converted.
Sort every temp into three groups with his foreman:
- Keep. Card checked, does the work without being babysat, shows up, and says yes when you ask if he'd want a spot on your crew. Convert these.
- Maybe. Good hand, but he likes moving job to job or hasn't said yes. Ask him straight. If the answer is "maybe," believe it.
- Replace. Can't run work, doesn't show, or his card doesn't match what he can do. Leave him on the agency until his replacement is on site, then end the assignment.
Pull how many hours each "keep" has billed. Conversion fees usually drop with hours, so the order you convert in can be worth thousands per hand. Temp-to-hire conversion fees, explained has the worked example on when waiting is cheaper than buying out.
05Read the agreement before you make one offer
The staffing agreement decides what converting costs, and some clauses reach a year past the job.
What published staffing terms say:
- Fee by hours. Robert Half's terms on a public cooperative contract charge a conversion fee that steps down as hours are billed, reaching zero after 640 hours in one division.
- Notice or a penalty. Reliable Staffing's published terms let you elect to hire after 520 consecutive hours. Hire earlier and you pay a prorated 20% of annual salary. Hire without telling them and there's a 10% violation fee on top.
- The tail. Robert Half's fee applies if you hire him "within twelve months after the last day of the assignment," including through another agency. Reliable's runs 12 months from the start of the assignment.
Check yours for the fee schedule, whether overtime hours count, the tail, the notice step, and any non-solicit or liquidated damages clause. Put each answer on your electrical staffing agreement checklist. When you're converting dozens of hands, ask the agency in writing for one price for the group. This is not legal advice. Have your lawyer read the clauses before you hire anyone around them.
06The step plan
Run it in this order so you never have an empty slot on the job.
- Count. Every temp, his hours billed, and which agency sent him.
- Sort. Keep, maybe, replace, with each foreman.
- Read the agreement. Fee schedule, tail, notice step, non-solicit.
- Set your pay and benefits first. BLS puts the median for electricians at employment services firms at $57,760 a year, under $61,570 at electrical contractors (May 2025). A converted hand will compare your offer to his agency check, so make it clearly better.
- Convert the keeps in the order their fees hit bottom, giving notice the way the agreement says.
- Hire direct for the rest. One contractor told us job boards bring him "the guys that are sitting on the couch 'cause somebody else fired them." Screen hard for the years and the work you need.
- Swap one for one. End a temp's assignment only when his direct replacement is on site and working.
- Keep a few temps for peaks. Energization pushes and short surges are what agencies are good for. Your core crew should be yours.
Before the first conversion, call your comp carrier and payroll service. Your headcount, comp premium and unemployment exposure all go up when the hands move to your payroll.
If you want your own crew instead of an agency's, see the electricians we already have near you. No money up front. If you don't hire, you don't pay.
Got more work than guys?
We already found them: 238 qualified electricians, 5+ years each. See who we have near you. No money up front. If you don't hire, you don't pay.
See who we haveFAQFAQs
Can I hire a temp electrician away from the staffing agency?
Usually yes, but read the agreement first. Most charge a conversion fee if you hire him before a set number of hours or within a set time, often 12 months, and some add a penalty if you skip the notice step. Hiring him through a different agency or as a 1099 doesn't get around the clauses we've read.
Is it cheaper to keep temps or hire permanent electricians?
It depends on the markup and how long the work runs. At 30 to 40% markups, direct hire usually wins on any long job. At 1.16 to 1.2, the hourly saving is small or gone once you add benefits, so the case for converting is keeping the crew and the next job.
Do temp electricians want to go permanent?
Some do and some like moving job to job. Ask each one in the first weeks, and believe a "maybe." Convert the ones who say yes and can do the work.
How many temps should I keep after converting?
Enough to cover peaks you can see coming, like an energization push or a short surge, and no more. The hands who'll be there for the whole job and the next one belong on your payroll.
What does a 1.2 markup mean?
The agency bills you 1.2 times what it pays the hand. On a $40 an hour hand that's $48 an hour, an $8 spread. About $4.89 of that covers payroll taxes and comp at the BLS construction average, and the rest is the agency's recruiting, overhead and profit.
Sources
- Bureau of Labor Statistics, Employer Costs for Employee Compensation, Table 4, June 2026
- Bureau of Labor Statistics, Occupational Outlook Handbook, Electricians (median wage by industry, May 2025)
- Robert Half temporary staffing terms and pricing, public cooperative contract TS06-21 (conversion fee scale, 12-month clause)
- Reliable Staffing, Staffing Agreement Terms and Conditions, updated March 2025
