How long before you know a new electrician will work out?

A new electrician probation period that works: what a foreman can tell on day 1, week 1, day 30 and day 90, the at-will catch, and final pay rules.

Updated November 2, 202611 min read8 sources

Photo: MTA Capital Construction Mega Projects, Wikimedia Commons (CC BY 2.0)

A good foreman knows if a new electrician can do the work in 1 to 3 days. Whether he'll show up, stay safe and fit the crew takes about 90 days. So set a 90-day new electrician probation period with checks on day 1, week 1, day 30 and day 90, and write down what you see at each one.

01Why you find out on day 3

You find out on day 3 because the interview tests talking and the job tests hands.

One commercial contractor told us: "All these guys say 10 years' experience. You interview them, you bring them in, we do a whole orientation and stuff, and then, like, within three days my foreman says, 'He sucks. Get rid of him.'"

A man can talk through a job he watched someone else run. He can't fake an offset on EMT. The fix starts before the hire, with a 30-minute bench test and a card check, but some misses still get through. The probation period catches them early and on paper.

Every week you carry a man who can't do the work costs wages, foreman time and rework. What a bad journeyman hire costs puts a number on three weeks of it. The checkpoints below cut that to days and help you keep the good ones; how to keep good electricians from leaving covers the rest.

02What you can tell on day 1

On day 1 you can tell if he showed up ready, and that's about it.

Don't judge his skill on day 1. Judge the things that don't need a learning curve.

Day 1 checkPass looks like
On timeEarly. On a jobsite everything starts early
ToolsHas the hand tools you listed in the offer, in working shape
PPEBoots, glasses, gloves, the rated gear the job calls for
PaperworkCard, OSHA card if the job needs one, I-9 documents
Safety talkListens, asks where the panels are hot, signs the sheet
AttitudeAsks how you run it here before telling you how he ran it

That last line matters more than it looks. Another owner told us what gets a new hand cut on the spot: "You come in here sideways and act like you know everything, I'm gonna get rid of you the same day."

Before he touches anything, give him the safety orientation for that site. Federal OSHA rules for construction say the employer "shall instruct each employee in the recognition and avoidance of unsafe conditions" on his job (29 CFR 1926.21(b)(2)). Have him sign that he got it, with the date.

03What you can tell by the end of week 1

By the end of week 1 your foreman knows if the man can do journeyman work, because he's watched him do it.

Have the foreman pair him with a lead, not a laborer, and hand him real tasks on purpose in the first five days. Then the foreman checks off what he saw. What a journeyman should do on day one has the full list by type of work. The short version:

  1. Bends. A 90, an offset and a kick on EMT, on the mark, without a helper doing the math.
  2. Terminates. Clean strips, right torque, neat in the can.
  3. Reads the prints. Can he find his circuits on the sheet and say what goes in first?
  4. Works hot work safely. Tests before touching. Never assumes a circuit is dead.
  5. Runs his own task. Takes a piece of the job and finishes it without being walked through each step.
  6. Shows up every day. Five for five, on time, no call-ins.

If he misses on 1 to 4, he's not the hand he said he was. Don't wait for day 90 on that. Write down what the foreman saw, pay him for every hour, and let him go.

If he passes 1 to 4 but misses on 5, you may have a solid 5-year hand who sold himself as a 10-year one. That can still be a good hire at the right rate. Tell him straight.

04What you can tell by day 30

By day 30 you can tell if he's consistent, safe when nobody's watching, and someone the crew wants around.

Day 30 shows what he does on a normal Tuesday. The same contractor runs a two-week check-in with the site foreman: "How's it going? Is he all right?" A 15-minute sit-down around day 14 and again at day 30 works for most shops.

At day 30, ask the foreman five questions and write down the answers:

  • Has he missed a day, been late, or left early? How many times?
  • Any safety calls: a near miss, gear left off, a box worked hot without a reason?
  • Is his work getting checked less now than in week 1?
  • Would the crew pick him for their side of the job?
  • Is he the rank you're paying him for: helper, apprentice, journeyman, lead?

Then ask him what's slowing him down. A new hand can sour in the first month over things you could fix in a day: no material, a foreman who never talks to him, or pulling wire when he was hired to run work.

Pay close attention to safety in this stretch. A 2026 Travelers report on more than 1.2 million workers' comp claims from 2021 to 2025 found that 44% of construction injuries involved workers in their first year on the job, as reported by Building Design + Construction, May 11, 2026. The new man doesn't know where your hazards are yet. Your foreman does.

05What you can tell by day 90

By day 90 you know if he's someone you'd want on the next job, and that's the real decision.

A man who is still with you, still on time and still getting better at day 90 is usually a keeper. The contractor above put the line a little further out: "If they last four months, then all right, they're probably pretty decent." Pick your number, 90 days or four months, and use it for everyone.

At day 90, the foreman fills in one sheet:

Day 90 questionAnswer
Attendance: days missed, times lateA number, not "fine"
Safety: any incidents or near missesDates and what happened
Skill: the rank he's working atHelper, apprentice, journeyman, lead
Next step: what he should learn nextOne thing, like running a crew of two
Keep him on the next job?Yes or no, and why

Then meet with him. Tell him where he stands, what his rate is going forward, and when his next review is. If benefits start at 90 days, start them that day without him having to ask. If you promised a raise at 90 days, give it on time.

If it's a no at day 90, say so and why, using what's on the sheets. By then nothing in that conversation should surprise him.

If your crew is short and you'd rather be running these check-ins than chasing applicants, see the electricians we already have near you. No money up front. If you don't hire, you don't pay.

06Does a probation period protect you legally?

In an at-will state, a probation label doesn't add much, and it can hurt you if he reads it as a promise.

The Texas Workforce Commission says there is "no particular legal significance" to a probationary period, since Texas is an employment at will state (TWC, Probationary Periods). It warns that the word makes people believe their job is safe after the period ends and they can only be fired for cause, and that this belief leads to lawsuits. Its advice: if you use one, say in writing that finishing it "does not change the employment at will relationship."

Montana is different. Under Montana's Wrongful Discharge from Employment Act, a firing after the probationary period ends is wrongful if it isn't for good cause (Mont. Code Ann. 39-2-904). If you don't set a probationary period when he starts, the law sets one at 12 months, and with extensions it can't run past 18 months (Mont. Code Ann. 39-2-910). If you hire in Montana, set the period in writing on day 1 and do your day-90 review on time.

Anywhere you hire, at-will doesn't cover a firing for an illegal reason, like retaliation for reporting a safety problem or discrimination. That's another reason to write down what the foreman saw. Hiring law basics for electrical contractors covers the rest of the paperwork. Rules change, so check with your state labor department or a lawyer before you build a policy around them.

07Write down why, every time

A short note at each checkpoint is your best protection and your best training tool.

Keep it simple. Date, who wrote it, what he did, what you told him. "10/14: Bent a 3-point saddle on 3/4 EMT, 1 inch off center, twice. Showed him. Retest Friday." That's enough.

The notes do three jobs:

  1. They make the call fair. The same checks for every new hand.
  2. They back you up. If a firing is ever questioned, you have dated facts, not memory.
  3. They show you your hiring. A year of day-3 cuts shows which ads and questions let the wrong men through.

Check his card the same way you'd check anyone's, on day 1, and file the printout with the date (how to verify an electrician's license). A license that doesn't match what he told you is the fastest answer you'll get.

08Cutting him loose the right way

Let him go in person, say why in one or two sentences, and pay him on time under your state's rules.

  1. Do it the day you decide. Dragging it out costs you both.
  2. Say why, plainly. "We needed a man who could run pipe on his own, and the foreman's seen that it's not there yet." No speech.
  3. Get your stuff back. Keys, fuel card, company tools, the truck. Have a list.
  4. Pay him right. Every hour worked, including the last day.

Final pay timing is set by your state, not federal law. The Department of Labor says employers are not required by federal law to give former employees their final paycheck immediately, but some states require it (DOL, Last Paycheck). Two examples of how far apart states are:

StateFinal pay when you fire himSource
CaliforniaImmediately, at the time of terminationCalifornia DIR
TexasWithin 6 calendar days of dischargeTexas Workforce Commission

California can add a waiting time penalty of up to 30 days of his daily pay if you willfully pay late (California DIR). Check your own state's labor department before your first cut, so you're not looking it up while he waits.

Got more work than guys?

We already found them: 238 qualified electricians, 5+ years each. See who we have near you. No money up front. If you don't hire, you don't pay.

See who we have

FAQFAQs

How long should a probation period be for a new electrician?

Ninety days is a sound default, with checks on day 1, week 1 and day 30 along the way. Skill shows in the first week; showing up, safety and fit take longer. Some use four months. Pick one length and use it for every new hire.

Can I fire a new electrician during probation for any reason?

In an at-will state you can let anyone go for any legal reason, during probation or after. You can't fire for an illegal reason, like retaliation for a safety complaint or discrimination. Montana is different: after the probationary period ends, a firing needs good cause.

Do I have to pay a new hire for his first day if I send him home?

Yes. Pay him for every hour he worked, including orientation and the day you let him go. When the final check is due depends on your state; California requires it right away when you fire someone.

Should I give a new journeyman a raise after 90 days?

Only if you promised one or he earned one. If the offer said 90 days, pay it on day 90 without him asking. If he's working at a lower rank than he was hired for, tell him at day 90 what he needs to show to get there.

What's the difference between a probation period and an introductory period?

In an at-will state, usually nothing legally. Some shops say "introductory period" so a new hand doesn't think he's guaranteed a job once it ends. Whatever you call it, write that finishing it doesn't change at-will employment.