How to hire electricians who already work for someone else
How to recruit electricians from competitors legally: where working journeymen hear about a move, the offer that gets one to pull the pin, what to avoid.
You can recruit electricians from competitors as long as you hire the man and not the other shop's files. The FTC's national noncompete rule was removed on February 12, 2026, so state law decides whether any clause he signed holds. Reach him through your crew, the trade around you and ads written for men who aren't looking, then make an offer worth leaving a job for.
Most of the hands you want are already working. In the AGC and NCCER 2026 survey (September 3, 2026), 87% of construction firms had openings for hourly craft, and 88% of those said the jobs were as hard or harder to fill than a year before. One commercial contractor summed up the problem on a call with us: "I would love to poach their people. But how do you get to them?"
This post answers that. For every other place to look, start with where to find journeyman electricians to hire.
01Is it legal to hire an electrician from a competitor?
Yes, in general: an electrician is free to take a better job, and you're free to offer him one.
The lines are about paper and about deals between shops, not about the hire itself. This is general information as of November 2026, not legal advice. Run anything unusual past an employment lawyer in the state where he works.
His noncompete, if he has one
There's no national noncompete ban and no national permission. The FTC says its rule "is not in effect and it is not enforceable." A court stopped it on August 20, 2024, the FTC moved to drop its appeal on September 5, 2025, and the rule was removed on February 12, 2026.
So it comes down to the state. Minnesota, for one, says "any covenant not to compete contained in a contract or agreement is void and unenforceable" (Minn. Stat. 181.988). Other states enforce some noncompetes. The state-by-state picture is in do non-competes work for electricians.
Ask him early: "Did you sign anything when you hired on?" If he did, get a copy before you make the offer, not after he's given notice.
Non-solicits and confidentiality clauses
These often hold even where noncompetes don't. Minnesota's own ban says it doesn't cover nondisclosure agreements or nonsolicitation agreements that protect customer lists.
A non-solicit usually stops him from going after his old shop's customers, and sometimes its employees. A confidentiality clause covers things like bid numbers and pricing. Neither one usually stops a J-man from pulling wire for you.
What he can't bring
Hire his hands and his head. Leave everything else behind.
- No customer lists, contact sheets or phone exports.
- No bids, takeoffs, estimates or pricing.
- No drawings, submittals or job files from his old shop.
- No pitching his old shop's customers in his first months if he signed a non-solicit.
Say it out loud on the first call: "Don't bring anything from them. I don't want it." It protects you, and it tells him what kind of shop you run.
The deal you can't make
Never agree with another contractor not to hire each other's people. The DOJ and FTC's Antitrust Guidelines for Business Activities Affecting Workers (January 2025) say competing businesses "may be committing an antitrust crime" if they agree "not to recruit, solicit, or hire workers or to fix wages." That covers deals that are "written or unwritten, or spoken or unspoken," and even an agreement to ask permission before hiring the other shop's hand.
The same goes for agreeing on rates. A handshake with the shop down the road to "keep J-man pay at $40" is the same problem.
02How working journeymen hear about a move
A working J-man hears about your job from people he trusts, not from a job board.
Another owner told us the same thing a different way: "All those guys are already with other companies." He'd tried Facebook and Indeed and gotten interviews, but not the hire. One commercial contractor said referrals were his best source by far and there were never enough of them. That's the pattern. The hands you want don't apply. Somebody tells them.
These are the places where somebody tells them:
- Your own crew. Your hands have worked beside half the good men in town. Ask by name: "Who's the best J-man you've worked with in the last two years?" Then pay for it. How to set an electrician referral bonus shows how to size one and when to pay it.
- The jobsite. Your foreman sees the other subs' crews every day on a shared job. He knows who's good, who's stuck behind a bad foreman and whose phase is ending. Ask him every Friday.
- The supply house counter. The counter guys and your reps know which shops are slow and who's unhappy. Leave a card with the rate on it.
- The GC's super. He's watched every electrical crew on his last ten jobs. He won't make a call for you, but he'll often tell you who was good.
- Former foremen. A foreman who left you on good terms knows where his old hands went. A call costs nothing.
- Ads written for men who aren't looking. A working man scrolls past "Now hiring." He stops for a rate, hours, how long the work runs and who runs it. How to write a journeyman electrician job ad that gets calls has the template.
What to say on the first call
Keep it short and give him numbers he can hold up against his check.
- Who you are, what you build and how long you've been around.
- The rate, the hours, and what's in backlog for the next six months.
- Who his foreman would be.
- One question: "What would make a move worth it to you?"
Then stop talking. If he says rate, you know where you stand. If he says steady work, home every night or a foreman who backs him, you can often win without a bidding war.
Don't run down his current shop. He likes some of the men there, and he'll repeat what you said. Talk about your job only.
If you'd rather have licensed hands brought to you than make all those calls yourself, see the electricians we already have near you. We already found them, and every one gets a recorded call from our hiring team before he's in front of you. No money up front. If you don't hire, you don't pay.
03The offer that gets a working man to pull the pin
A working J-man moves for the whole check, steady work and a foreman worth working for, in that order more often than not.
He's comparing your offer to a job he already knows. Every gap you leave, he fills with the worst guess. So put it all in one page:
| What he weighs | What to tell him |
|---|---|
| Rate | One number, hourly. Not "DOE" or "up to" |
| Hours | 40, 50 or 6-10s, and how often OT really runs |
| How long it lasts | What's in backlog, and what's next after this job |
| Who runs it | His foreman's name and years |
| Benefits | What starts day one and what starts at 30 or 90 days |
| The truck | Take-home or not, fuel card |
What a raise to move costs you
Here's an example you can check. Say he makes $38 an hour now and you offer $41. The $3 difference over 2,080 straight-time hours is $6,240 a year. That's the number to weigh against a month with one hand short.
Don't try to beat a 6-10s check week for week if you can't. A man on a job with heavy overtime and no next job lined up is worried about the day it ends. Sell him the year: steady 40s or 50s, a backlog he can see, and home every night.
Make it fast
His shop will counter once he gives notice. Make your offer within a day of the talk, in writing, with a start date that lets him give notice the way he wants to. A man who leaves his old boss right is the man you want.
04Hiring from a shop you sub to or work beside
If you sub to a contractor, sub alongside one, or trade work back and forth, hiring his people costs more than a rate.
Decide your own rules ahead of time. You can't agree on them with the other shop, but you can set them for yourself:
- Let him come to you. On a shared job, don't pitch the other sub's hands on site. If one of them calls you, that's his choice.
- Hire one, not the crew. Taking a foreman and his three best hands in one week can sink the other shop's job and your standing with the GC.
- Pay your number, not a bump. Offer what you'd offer anyone at his level. If you jump $5 over market to win one man, your own crew finds out by Friday, and the other shop does the same to you next month.
- Don't recruit off a job you're running together. Wait until the job is done, or until he reaches out.
That's how you avoid a bidding war. Your crew is also on someone else's list. The other side of this post is how to keep your crew from getting poached, and when the call comes for one of yours, read when a competitor offers your journeyman $2 more before you answer.
05Before he starts
Check him like any other hire, no matter how good his name is on the street.
- Look up his card on the state board by license class. How to verify an electrician's license covers the lookup.
- Read anything he signed at his old shop, before he gives notice.
- Set a start date that respects his notice. Let him leave his old shop the way he wants to.
- Put him on your work, not his old shop's. Keep him off his old shop's customers for his first months, whether or not he signed a non-solicit.
Got more work than guys?
We already found them: 238 qualified electricians, 5+ years each. See who we have near you. No money up front. If you don't hire, you don't pay.
See who we haveFAQFAQs
Is it unethical to hire electricians from competitors?
Hiring a man who wants a better job is normal in the trade. What crosses the line is taking files, customer lists or bid numbers, or pitching a whole crew off a job you're running together. Treat the other shop the way you'd want yours treated.
Can a competitor sue me for hiring his electrician?
He can sue over a contract the man signed or over files the man took. That's why you ask about noncompetes and non-solicits before the offer and tell him to bring nothing.
Can I agree with another contractor not to hire each other's people?
No. The DOJ and FTC say agreements between businesses not to recruit, solicit or hire each other's workers can be an antitrust crime, written or not. Set your own rules instead and keep them to yourself.
How do I find out what a competitor pays his journeymen?
Ask the hand on the first call what it would take, and watch the other shop's ads. Don't call the other owner to compare rates. The same DOJ and FTC guidelines warn that swapping pay information with a shop that competes with you for hands may break antitrust law, even without an agreement.
Should I pay a recruiter to call my competitor's hands?
You can, but you're paying for calls your crew and foreman could make for a referral bonus. Start with the people who already know the good hands, and add outside help if those run dry.
Sources
- Federal Trade Commission, Noncompete Rule (status page)
- U.S. Department of Justice and Federal Trade Commission, Antitrust Guidelines for Business Activities Affecting Workers, January 2025
- Minnesota Statutes 181.988, Covenants not to compete void in employment agreements
- AGC and NCCER, 2026 construction workforce survey release, September 3, 2026
