What gets a new electrician let go in the first week

New electrician first week: what gets a journeyman cut by day 3, what the foreman is watching day 1 to day 5, and what to ask before you start.

Updated November 2, 202610 min read4 sources

Photo: Los Muertos Crew, Pexels

A new electrician usually gets let go in the first week for one of four things: work that doesn't match the years he claimed, walking in like he knows better than the crew, showing up late or leaving early, and living on his phone. Owners on our calls this fall said their foremen make the call in 2 or 3 days. Skill gets you hired. The first week keeps you there.

01How fast does a foreman decide on a new hand?

Fast. On most commercial jobs the foreman has a read on you by day 2 or 3, and the owner usually goes with it.

The owner of a growing open shop told us his new hires all say they have 10 years. "You interview them, you bring them in, we do a whole orientation and stuff, and then, like, within three days my foreman says, 'He sucks. Get rid of him.'" Weak hands get pulled off the site "on day two or three," he said.

His shop does a two-week check-in with the site foreman and a review at four months. That's one shop, not a rule, but the shape is common: a quick early look, then a longer one. If you make it through the first two weeks clean, you're past the part where most new hands get cut.

That speed isn't personal. A foreman running a crew on a schedule can't carry a man who slows the rest down. He'd rather send you home on Wednesday than find out on the punch list.

02The four things that get a new hand cut

These four came up again and again from the owner side, in the words they used.

1. The work doesn't match what you said. This is the big one. If you told them 10 years of commercial and you can't run a straight rack of EMT, the foreman knows by lunch. He doesn't care that you rounded up. He cares that he has to redo it. Before you start, be straight about what you've done a lot of and what you've only seen. What contractors check before they hire a journeyman covers the bending test, terminations and prints, which is the same stuff he's watching on day one.

2. Coming in sideways. One commercial contractor put it plainly: "You come in here sideways and act like you know everything, I'm gonna get rid of you the same day." He wasn't talking about skill. He was talking about attitude. A new man who argues about every method, talks down to the apprentices or tells the foreman how his last shop did it is gone fast, even if he's good.

3. Late in, early out. The same owner said what he needs from a foreman is someone who tightens up on the guys who "want to leave early, want to be late." On a new job you don't have any credit built up. Ten minutes late on day two reads as who you are.

4. The phone. He also said you have to tell guys "don't be on the telephones." Check it at break and lunch. If you have to take a call during work, tell your foreman why before it rings.

Notice what's not on the list. Nobody said "he didn't know where the material was" or "he asked too many questions." New guys are expected to ask. They're not expected to fake it.

03What the foreman is watching, day 1 to day 5

He's watching whether you show up ready, do what you said you can do, and make his day easier instead of harder.

DayWhat he's watchingWhat you do
1Are you on time, with your tools, in the right PPE, and paying attention at orientation?Be early. Bring your full hand tools. Listen at the safety talk.
2Can you do the work you claimed, at a normal pace?Ask where he wants you. Do it right first, then fast.
3Do you fit the crew? Do you take direction?Do it his way. Help the apprentice without showing off.
4Can he leave you alone on a task?Finish what he gave you. Clean up your area. Ask before you change anything.
5Is the end of the week as good as the start?Same time in, same pace, no early Friday.

Orientation isn't just paperwork. Under OSHA's construction rules, "the employer shall instruct each employee in the recognition and avoidance of unsafe conditions" (29 CFR 1926.21(b)(2)). The foreman knows the shop has to cover that. A man who looks at his phone through the safety talk tells him a lot.

04What to ask before day one

Ask the boring questions before you start, so day one isn't spent figuring out where to be.

  1. Start time and where. The yard or the job? Gate time or tools-on time? Where do you park?
  2. Who you report to. Get the foreman's name and number. Text him the night before: "This is [your name], starting tomorrow, see you at 6:30."
  3. The tools list. What the shop expects you to bring and what it supplies. Hand tools are usually on you, power tools and benders on the shop, but ask. If they take tools out of your check, federal law says the deduction can't push you below minimum wage or eat into overtime (DOL Fact Sheet #16). What a shop can and can't take out of your check covers the rest.
  4. The truck. Do you drive yourself, ride with someone or get a truck? Who pays fuel?
  5. What you'll be doing the first week. Rough-in, trim, service, gear? It tells you which tools to have sharp.
  6. Badging, drug test, paperwork. Anything that has to clear before you can walk on the site.
  7. When benefits start. Get the date. A group health plan can't make you wait more than 90 days (29 CFR 2590.715-2708).

Most of these belong in the conversation before you take the job. The questions to ask an electrical contractor before you say yes has the full list, from job length to per diem days.

05How to handle "that's not how we did it"

Do it their way, ask why once, and save your better idea until you've earned it.

Every shop has its own way of doing things: how they strap pipe, how they label, how they land neutrals in a panel, how they lay out a room. Your last shop's way might be better. It doesn't matter on day three.

Here's how to handle it without getting tagged as the guy who knows everything:

  • First time, do it their way. Even if it's slower.
  • Ask, don't tell. "How do you want these supported?" lands better than "We always did it this way."
  • Offer an idea once, privately. After a couple of weeks, if you have a faster way, show the foreman on one run. If he says no, drop it.
  • Never correct the foreman in front of the crew. Not even when you're right.

The exception is safety and code. If someone wants you to work it hot with no reason and no PPE, or skip something that won't pass, say so plainly and go to the foreman. That's not attitude. What you can refuse on an unsafe job site covers where that line sits.

06The first 90 days

Many shops treat the first few months as a trial. Some call it probation, some don't name it, but either way, they're still deciding.

Ask the shop how long its trial runs and what happens at the end. The shop on our calls uses a two-week check-in and a four-month review. Other shops set their own length, and some don't have one on paper at all.

Probation or not, most jobs can end any day. The Department of Labor says that outside of discrimination, whistleblower and complaint protections, a firing is generally "subject only to any private contract between the employer and employee or a labor contract" (DOL, Termination). If you're working under a collective bargaining agreement, read what it says. If you're not, the trial period is mostly about you showing them, and them showing you.

That second part matters. Use the first 90 days to check them, too:

  • Is the work steady, or is there talk of slowing down after this phase?
  • Does the foreman know the work, and does the PM back him?
  • Is material on site when you need it?
  • Did the check match the offer, every week?

If you want to know whether the job will run past this phase, how to tell if a job will short-term you has the questions to ask.

07If the job isn't what they said

Give it a week or two to see if it's a bad start or a bad shop, then decide.

Some things settle down. The first week on a new crew is always a little rough, you're on the worst tasks, and nobody knows you yet. That's normal.

Other things don't settle down. These are worth pulling the pin over:

  • The check doesn't match the offer, and they don't fix it when you ask.
  • The hours aren't what they said. Say you were told 50-hour weeks and you're getting 32.
  • The work isn't what they said. You signed on for commercial and you're digging trench every day.
  • Unsafe work is normal there, not a one-off.
  • The job is ending already and there's no next one.

If it's one of those, talk to the foreman or the office first. Give them one chance to fix it. If they don't, leave the right way: how to quit an electrical job without burning bridges covers notice, the tools and the truck, and your last check. Two quick moves in a row look bad to the next shop, so be sure.

If you're still deciding whether a move was worth it, put the old job and the new one side by side the way the guide to comparing electrician job offers lays it out: rate, hours, per diem, how long it runs, and when benefits start.

08A short checklist for week one

Print it or screenshot it.

  1. Text the foreman the night before.
  2. Show up 15 minutes early every day of week one.
  3. Bring a full set of hand tools, clean and labeled.
  4. Listen at orientation. Phone in the truck.
  5. Ask where he wants you, then do it his way.
  6. Be honest about what you haven't done much of.
  7. Clean up your area before you leave.
  8. Stay until he cuts you loose, even on Friday.

Before you settle in, know where you stand. Get your local pay report to see what electricians with your license make near you. Takes about a minute and your boss never hears about it.

See what your license pays near you.

Tap a few answers and see what electricians with your license make in your area. Free, about a minute, and your boss never hears about it.

Get my local pay report

FAQFAQs

Can I get fired in my first week as an electrician?

Yes. Most jobs can end at any time unless a contract or labor agreement says otherwise, and a trial period doesn't change that. The owners we talk with say their foremen usually decide on a new hand within 2 or 3 days.

What should I bring on my first day at a new electrical job?

Your full hand tools, your PPE, your license card, your ID and whatever paperwork the office asked for. Ask before day one what the shop supplies, so you're not missing a meter or a bender you were told to bring.

What if the foreman does things differently than my last shop?

Do it his way. Ask why if you need to understand it, but save your own method until you've been there a couple of weeks. The exception is safety and code: say something right away.

Is it bad to quit a new electrical job after a week?

It depends why. If the pay, hours or work aren't what they promised, and they won't fix it, leaving is fair. If it's just a rough first week, give it time. Two short stints in a row are hard to explain at the next interview.

When do benefits start at a new electrical job?

It's up to the shop's plan. Federal rules say a group health plan can't make you wait more than 90 days. Get the exact date in writing before you give notice where you are.